Is Private College Worth It? Analyzing California's Top Universities' Tuition vs Earnings

Join us for free SAT Mock Test and Trial Class! Get expert SAT coaching from our experienced
SAT counselors. Prepare for success with the New Digital SAT - Sign Up for free SAT prep now.

The tuition disparity between public and private universities is startling. According to the latest figures from the College Board in 2023, in-state students at public universities pay an average tuition of $11,260, while out-of-state students face fees of $29,150. In stark contrast, private university tuition averages $41,540—nearly three times the cost for in-state public university students!

California College Enrollment: The Cost-Benefit Analysis

image of a College University in California

Parents often believe that private universities offer superior academic resources and a more rigorous academic environment. Many of America's top-ranked universities are private, suggesting that the higher cost may be justified by the quality of education provided. But the staggering difference between educational costs has left many bewildered, questioning how long it will take college graduates to recoup their tuition expenses through their earnings.

Is attending a private college worth the investment? This article focuses on universities in California, offering a detailed analysis of whether private universities in the state provide a worthwhile return on investment.

California College Graduates 10-Year Earnings vs. Costs

According to the research by the Center for Education and Productivity at Georgetown University, for private school students, tuition fees are generally proportional to their income ten years after graduation. Higher tuition tends to correlate with higher future earnings.

California University alumni earning after 10 years vs the tuition costs

However, when comparing private universities with UC and CSU institutions, a different pattern emerges. Except for the top-tier private universities, most private university graduates have incomes clustered in the $250,000-$300,000 range, similar to those of UC graduates. In contrast, graduates from lower-ranked private universities typically earn less than their UC counterparts.

10-Year ROI Analysis: Top Private vs. UC and CSU Institutions in California

Let's take another look at the ROI (return on investment) for students' income at various colleges and universities in California after 10 years. The data shows significant changes in the relative positions of private schools.

Except for the top private universities, which continue to offer very high returns, most other private universities now have returns that are generally lower than those of UC and CSU institutions. In some cases, the return rate for certain private universities, particularly local art colleges, has even turned negative.

This phenomenon is further confirmed by the list of the top 10 income returns for college graduates in California. Apart from the top private colleges, all the schools on the list are UC and CSU institutions. Notably, the California Institute of Technology has surpassed Stanford, achieving the highest return on income among California universities, likely due to its strong technical programs. Additionally, UC Berkeley has emerged as the UC branch with the highest income and return rate, surpassing other UC campuses.

Top 10 California Universities ranked by ROI

1California Institute of Technology$510K$377KPrivate
2Stanford University$424K$360KPrivate
3Harvey Mudd College$491K$324KPrivate
Claremont Mckenna College
5CSU Maritime$366K$257KCSU
6UC Berkeley$323K$243KUC
7Cal Poly SLO$326K$223KCSU
8UC Los Angeles$292K$216KUC
9UC San Diego$276K$215KUC
10UC Irvine$286K$211KUC

It is worth noting that USC, a well-known private school in California, is not among the top 10 schools with the highest return rates. This is primarily due to its high tuition costs. Although USC graduates have an impressive average annual income of $333,000—exceeding that of all UC schools—the tuition fee of $77,000 is the third highest among all schools, surpassed only by Caltech and Stanford.

From this, we can conclude from the Georgetown University survey that the return rates of top private universities are very high. Despite their expensive tuition, the income of their graduates ten years post-graduation far exceeds their educational expenses. UC public universities also offer excellent value, with relatively low tuition and strong employment outcomes for students. In particular, UC Berkeley stands out with a significantly higher ROI compared to other UC campuses.

As the new application season draws near, 7EDU is here to provide support with your school selections and essays. Explore our event page for FREE counseling webinars.


Looking for counselor near you? From college admissions guidance to academic support, test prep, and more, 7EDU helps students achieve their goals.

Test Prep

Intensive SAT, ACT, and AP test prep tutoring course online or on-campus in Cupertino, CA. We offer FREE Mock Test and FREE Diagnostic Test.


Joining our online webinars, free trial classes, and on-site events at our campus in Cupertino, CA. 
California's SAT Seating Shortage